Benefit They’re Real Mascara (Review)
Benefit They’re Real Mascara, £18.50 – Boots | Benefit
I finally bit the bullet and decided to get myself a mini version of the ever so hyped up Benefit They’re Real Mascara. The moment I tried it for the first time, I knew my bank balance would never be the same again…
Retailing at a whooping £18.50 for a mere 8.5g, the Benefit They’re Real Mascara has caused quite a stir amongst makeup-lovers. But is it worth the hefty price tag? Without a shadow of a doubt, yes! This mascara offers pretty much everything you would want; long, thick, curled and separated lashes. The formulation is creamy without being too gloopy and it doesn’t smudge throughout the day.
This mascara is a dream to apply and it dries almost immediately. With one coat my lashes looked incredibly long, thick, separated and curled. Two coats made them look extremely full, and a third coat would have added quite some drama, but I was happy with two. I recommend curling your lashes beforehand if you have particularly straight lashes, but that’s not essential; I didn’t curl mine (as you can see on the ‘Before’ picture) and the results were fantastic!
Overall, this is a great mascara; it has stolen the crown from my previous all-time favourites Maybelline The Falsies Mascara and Rimmel ScandalEyes Show Off Mascara. The only downside of this mascara is the price; at nearly £20 it’s ridiculously expensive to keep repurchasing, but it’s definitely worth it. I might have to save it for special occasions, even though I’ve already used so much of it over the past week or so. I got the mini-version from Boots for about £9, so if you’re thinking about trying it, I’d recommend getting the mini one first.
Have you tried the Benefit They’re Real Mascara? Was it everything you wished or a total let down? Would you repurchase it?


42 Comments
Sara Baker
I never got on well with Benfit Bad Gal Lash but really like They’re Real. Your lashes look lovely using this mascara:)
Le Beauty Girl
I never tried Bad Gal but I heard lots of mixed reviews; They’Real has absolutely blown me away! x
Sara Baker
I never got on well with Benfit Bad Gal Lash but really like They’re Real. Your lashes look lovely using this mascara:)
♥ Natalie ♥
Wow, great result! I wanna try this out as well… <3
Le Beauty Girl
Definitely do. I’ve never recommended something as much as I recommend this mascara! :)
♥ Natalie ♥
Wow, great result! I wanna try this out as well… <3
Miss Melissa
i just tried it out also and I LOVED it
Le Beauty Girl
I kind of wish I had never tried it… it’s so good but so pricey! x
Miss Melissa
i just tried it out also and I LOVED it
katherine.parkes
I loveeee this stuff! x
http://thebeautyvisual.blogspot.co.uk
Le Beauty Girl
Me too :) x
katherine.parkes
I loveeee this stuff! x
http://thebeautyvisual.blogspot.co.uk
Rena
This is no doubt, hands down, my favorite mascara I’ve tried so far. Problem is, the price! I kind of wish I didn’t love it so much because then I wouldn’t be so tempted to buy it all the time! ;)
Le Beauty Girl
I totally agree with you. Why does it have to be so expensive? :( But I can’t live without it now! x
Rena
This is no doubt, hands down, my favorite mascara I’ve tried so far. Problem is, the price! I kind of wish I didn’t love it so much because then I wouldn’t be so tempted to buy it all the time! ;)
Le Beauty Girl
I totally agree with you. Why does it have to be so expensive? :( But I can’t live without it now! x
Le Beauty Girl
Me too :) x
Le Beauty Girl
I kind of wish I had never tried it… it’s so good but so pricey! x
zaamissbowtie
OMG> I never wanted to buy this just because it is so expensive, but now I just have to have it!
Le Beauty Girl
You have to! :) It’s probably one of the most hyped up products that live up to the hype. x
zaamissbowtie
OMG> I never wanted to buy this just because it is so expensive, but now I just have to have it!
Le Beauty Girl
Definitely do. I’ve never recommended something as much as I recommend this mascara! :)
Le Beauty Girl
I never tried Bad Gal but I heard lots of mixed reviews; They’Real has absolutely blown me away! x
Le Beauty Girl
You have to! :) It’s probably one of the most hyped up products that live up to the hype. x
anibani
it is a great mascara but its only downside is that it is so hard to take it off!
anibani
it is a great mascara but its only downside is that it is so hard to take it off!
Millie
Love this mascara, it’s my all time favorite! :) ♥
http://abeautyromancee.blogspot.co.uk/
http://abeautyromancee.blogspot.co.uk/
Millie
Love this mascara, it’s my all time favorite! :) ♥
http://abeautyromancee.blogspot.co.uk/
http://abeautyromancee.blogspot.co.uk/
Janika R.
Wanna try this out….
http://lovelybusybee.blogspot.com/
Janika R.
Wanna try this out….
http://lovelybusybee.blogspot.com/
Sandra Rytter Jensen
I really want to try this mascara! Heard so many good things about it (:
Sandra Rytter Jensen
I really want to try this mascara! Heard so many good things about it (:
Irina
You are flawless! I always thought this mascara looked too clumpy on people but it works really well with your eyelashes; maybe I’ll give it a shot!
Irina
You are flawless! I always thought this mascara looked too clumpy on people but it works really well with your eyelashes; maybe I’ll give it a shot!
Mellissa "Shia" Rondinelli
Thanks for reminding me … a got a sample size as a birthday treat from Sephora … I need to try it! Looks great on you!
Shia
World According to Shia
Mellissa "Shia" Rondinelli
Thanks for reminding me … a got a sample size as a birthday treat from Sephora … I need to try it! Looks great on you!
Shia
World According to Shia
Paula
love this post, i think i may have to try this mascara out once and for all :D
please check out my blog http://xobeautybypaulaxo.blogspot.co.uk/
Paula
love this post, i think i may have to try this mascara out once and for all :D
please check out my blog http://xobeautybypaulaxo.blogspot.co.uk/
Sajda Ouachtouki
I love this mascara! It’s very similar to the Buxom ones, which have been my favorite for years.
Sajda Ouachtouki
I love this mascara! It’s very similar to the Buxom ones, which have been my favorite for years.
Gen-zel D. Habab
Oh my! I so love this mascara. I’m planning to buy this soon as my mascaras are all empty. It works pretty well on your lashes, and you’re so pretty! Love it!
Sam Lanuza
It looks so natural. And you are so pretty dear :)